McMullin v. Leitch

Appeal from a judgment of the Superior Court of San Joaquin County, and from an order denying a new trial.

This was a proceeding by writ of review in the superior court to set aside and annul an ordinance of the supervisors of San Joaquin County declaring the Stockton and French Camp toll-road to be a free public highway, and to be opened to the public. The superior court rendered a decree annulling the ordinance as being in excess of the jurisdiction of the board of supervisors, and the supervisors appealed therefrom. It appeared that the Stockton and French Camp Turnpike Company was organized as a corporation May 20, 1867, and had built the toll-road in controversy in that year at a cost of thirty-five thousand dollars. The ordinance complained of was passed March 15,1S88, and it was claimed by the supervisors that, the franchise and charter of the corporation having expired after the lapse of twenty years from May 20, 1867, the road became, by operation of law, and could be declared, a public, highway. The plaintiff, on the other hand, who was a stockholder of the turnpike company, insisted that the ordinance of the supervisors was void, because no compensation was made or tendered for the construction or value of the road, which plaintiff claimed to be still the property of the stockholders.