People v. Napoli

COOPER, P. J.

Defendant was convicted in the superior court of the crime of murder in the second degree. He made a motion for a new trial, which was denied, and he appealed to this court from the order and judgment of conviction, which appeal has never been disposed of. After the said appeals had been perfected, and before the defendant’s bill of exceptions had been allowed and settled by the trial court, all the records of the proceedings in said cause were destroyed by the fire of April 18, 1906, and the record has never been restored.

The defendant, in May, 1907, made a second motion for a new trial under an act entitled “An Act providing for the

[80]

disposition of actions and proceedings in which hills of exceptions and statements on motion for a new trial have been lost or destroyed by conflagration or other public calamity,” approved March 25, 1907 (Stats. 1907, p. 998). The court denied the said second motion, and this appeal is from the latter order.

The act provides: “When any proposed bill of exceptions, or statement of the case on motion for a new trial, in action or proceedings, is lost or destroyed by reason of conflagration or other public calamity, and no other record of the proceedings upon the trial thereof can be obtained, and such action or proceeding is subject to review by motion for new trial, pending at the time of such loss or destruction, and it is by the court in which such action or proceeding is pending, deemed impossible or impracticable to restore such proceedings (and to settle a bill of exceptions or statement of the case containing such proceedings) so as to enable the court to review the judgment or order therein by motion for new trial, the court may grant a new trial of such action or proceeding if at the time of such loss or destruction a motion for new trial be pending therein, and such action or proceeding shall thereupon be tried anew. In order to grant such new trial, it shall be unnecessary to have any bill of exceptions or statement of the case settled, but upon the facts above recited being shown to the satisfaction of the court by affidavit or otherwise, the court shall have power in its discretion to grant such new trial.”

The act has reference to a trial court in which the “action or proceeding is pending.” It is therein provided that “the court may grant a new trial of such action or proceeding if at the time" of such loss or destruction a motion for a new trial be pending therein, and such action or proceeding shall thereupon be tried anew.”