People v. Zelaya

Opinion

ELKINGTON, Acting P. J.

Trial by jury having been waived by defendant James A. Zelaya (Zelaya), he was found guilty by the superior court of the crime of first degree burglary. He appeals from an order of probation conditional upon his service of one year in the county jail.

The sole contention of the appeal is stated as: “Trial court erred in finding the appellant guilty of first degree residential burglary.”

In his ensuing argument Zelaya admits that he had committed a burglary of the subject premises. The issue is narrowed to whether it was of the first degree or second degree. He insists that it was of the second degree and

not

burglary of an “inhabited dwelling house” as proscribed by Penal Code section 460.

We state the related evidence as it was presumably found true by the superior court.

The manager of a San Francisco apartment house resided on the first floor above its garage and basement. Early one morning he heard metallic sounds in the area below and suspicious, he called the police. Two police officers promptly arrived. Investigating, they observed that wire covering an 18 by 24 inch vent on the garage wall had somehow been cut, allowing

[75]

entrance to that portion of the building. At least two of the tenants’ automobiles were in the garage at the time. The officers noted that a nearby door leading to the building’s basement was ajar. They entered and walked down a hallway leading to several storage rooms for the tenants’ property. They observed that on at least two of the storage rooms the door locks had been freshly “jimmied.” Entering one of the storage rooms they found Zelaya and another. Their presence there was unexplained.

From the evidence, we opine, the trial court reasonably inferred that Zelaya and his companion had gained entry into the building’s garage through the damaged vent, from which point they entered the building’s hallway, and the tenants’ storage rooms.

Penal Code section 460 as here relevant provides: “Every burglary of an inhabited dwelling house ... is burglary of the first degree.”