Donovan v. Brown

Opinion

THE COURT.

Petitioners Robert Donovan, Elizabeth Elder, Bernard Klitzner, David Noble and James Stanbery, in an original proceeding before this court, seek a writ of mandate to compel respondents Edmund G. Brown, Jr., as Secretary of State, and Leonard Panish, Registrar-Recorder of the County of Los Angeles, to file their declarations as write-in candidates in the June 4, 1974, primary election pursuant to Elections Code sections 18601, 18602 and 18603 without requiring the payment of any fee or any proof of indigency.

Section 18603 of the Elections Code provides: “No name written upon a ballot in any state, county, city, city and county, or district election shall be counted for an office or nomination unless:

“(a) A declaration has been filed pursuant to Sections 18601 and 18602 declaring a write-in candidacy for that particular person for that particular office or nomination and

“(b) The fee required by Section 6555 is paid when the declaration of write-in candidacy is filed pursuant to Section 18602.”

On May 1, 1974, this court issued an alternative writ of mandate and a conditional order directing respondents, pending final termination of this proceeding, to file petitioners’ declarations as write-in candidates without requiring the payment of any fee or any proof of indigency but not

[573]

to count any votes cast for petitioners until and unless ordered by this court.

Petitioners urge that the United States Supreme Court in

Lubin

v.

Panish

(1974) 415 U.S. 709 [39 L.Ed.2d 702, 94 S.Ct 1315] declared unconstitutional the California filing fee system embodied in Elections Code sections 6552, 6553 and 6555 for lack of reasonable alternative means of ballot access. Respondents in their return and answer to the alternative writ of mandate issued by this court contend that

Lubin, supra,