Estate of Duncan

145 Cal.App.2d 612 (1956) Estate of DOROTHY DUNCAN, Deceased. JACQUES B. SNYDER, Appellant,

v.

MOTION PICTURE RELIEF FUND, INC. (a Corporation), Respondent.

California Court of Appeals.

Nov. 2, 1956. Willard R. Decker and Robert S. Dickerman for Appellant.

Alpern & Vallier and Robert Vallier for Respondents.

MOORE, P. J.

From a judgment determining heirship, Jacques Snyder appeals.

In her lifetime, decedent executed a holographic will. After making a number of bequests of $100 each and of treasured possessions of adornment, she closed with a residuary clause in the following words:

"If, after everything is paid up--that is, my debts--whatever money is left I would like to help, perhaps a secretary, at the Motion Picture Relief Fund."

After an order for partial distribution had been made, the executor petitioned for a determination of heirship. He alleged that the Motion Picture Relief Fund is incorporated and is licensed as a charitable nonprofit organization and prayed the court to determine and declare the rights of all persons to decedent's estate and to whom distribution should be made. Jacques B. Snyder, legatee of his grandfather's portrait, filed his "statement of claim of interest in estate."

After trial, the court found upon substantial evidence that decedent left but one living relative, to wit, the same Jacques B. Snyder, her first cousin; that at the time testatrix drew her will there existed the Motion Picture Relief Fund, Inc. which provides health and welfare services, assistance and benefits to indigent persons employed or formerly employed in motion picture industry who are in need thereof; that a person is so employed, irrespective of his occupation, if he contributes substantially to the making of film; secretaries who meet this test form a clearly identifiable class of persons eligible for relief from the Fund; that the Fund relies upon voluntary contributions and bequests in order to carry on its work, although this is not a condition for receiving or qualifying for its benefits; that testatrix was a secretary and was so employed for approximately 22 years; that the rights of persons or organizations claiming an interest in the residue of decedent's estate have not heretofore been determined by any judgment; that the only parties claiming an interest therein are the said Fund, Snyder and the executor, as trustee for secretaries as a class who are members of the Fund.